Black PVD coating on eyewear frames: how H&U Scheffler took adhesion under deformation to a new level
A decorative PVD coating is often judged by its colour first. Is the black uniform? Are the gloss level and surface appearance right? Are there stains or other visible defects?
For an eyewear frame, that is not enough. The frame is subjected to mechanical stress during manufacturing, when the lenses are fitted and in everyday use. A springy metal part deforms considerably and then returns to its original position. The coating has to follow this movement.
This is exactly where our project with H&U Scheffler GmbH from Markranstädt, Germany, a full-service partner to the eyewear industry, came in. AVALUXE refined the coating process together with the Scheffler team, directly on Scheffler's own coater. Scheffler continues to coat in-house – now with a coating that can take considerably more.

Delicate metal frame, high demands: the coating must not only look good but also follow every deformation of the frame.
The starting point
For years, Scheffler has coated components for eyewear frames made of spring-hard stainless steel in-house, on its own Protec PVD coater using magnetron sputtering. The black coating had proven itself in practice: uniform colour, a high-quality decorative appearance and good adhesion to the stainless steel.

Scheffler was not content to leave it there. The coating was also meant to survive very severe deformation of the part without visible cracks or spallation. The benchmark was a demanding customer-specific functional test: the coated part is bent by approximately 90°.
Colour and appearance held up in this test, too. At the points of highest strain, however, cracks and local delamination appeared. The test revealed where there was still room for improvement.

Why even a well-adhering coating reaches its limits
During bending, the outer side of the part is under tension and the inner side under compression. How much the coating is actually strained depends not only on the bending angle but above all on the bending radius, the material thickness and the geometry of the part. A bending angle of 90° alone is therefore not a complete test specification.
On top of that, every PVD coating carries residual stress as soon as it has been deposited. Tensile stress promotes cracking; compressive stress can promote delamination and spallation. The stress from bending adds to this existing state. Even a coating that performs flawlessly in everyday use can therefore exceed its limit under extreme deformation.
In addition, spring steel and a hard coating deform differently. The steel yields elastically and partly plastically; the hard coating barely yields at all – it cracks. Stress peaks build up at the interface. Studies on sputter-coated stainless steel wires show that a single crack can trigger large-area delamination along the interface. With an adapted interface, by contrast, finer cracks and much more limited delamination appeared only at considerably higher deformation.
In other words: high hardness, a good colour and a passed static adhesion test do not guarantee sufficient bendability.
Our analysis: looking at the whole system
We did not treat the task as an isolated colour or adhesion issue. Together with Scheffler, we examined the entire system: from the substrate and its pretreatment through the interface, the deposition conditions, coating thickness and coating architecture to residual stress and the actual load on the part.
The key was distinguishing between two failure modes. In cohesive failure, the coating cracks within itself. In adhesive failure, it detaches at an interface. In practice, the two often follow each other directly: a crack forms first, stresses concentrate at its tip, and from there delamination spreads along the interface.
The position, direction and distribution of the cracks in the bend test therefore showed us where to start. Just as important was whether the coating detached directly from the stainless steel or whether the failure occurred within the coating system.
Refined on the customer's own coater
Based on this analysis, we refined the proven process together with the Scheffler team, directly on their production coater. Production and know-how stay with the customer.
Which parameters, process steps and coating elements were changed remains confidential. This much can be said: it was not a single machine parameter. Interface, coating growth, residual stress and deformability were re-tuned as a whole.
A standard recipe would not have helped here. Material, geometry, colour, type of load and the existing coater have to be considered together. A multilayer or gradient coating that works for one part is not automatically suitable for the next.
The result
After the process had been refined, the part was recoated and subjected to the same bend test.
The uniform black appearance was retained. Bending by approximately 90° produced no cracks or spallation visible to the naked eye. The coating remained fully intact even in the highly deformed area.

The already good coating has thus reached a new level: its proven decorative quality now comes with considerably higher adhesion under deformation. The result applies to the agreed test and the tested part geometry; requirements such as repeated bending, corrosion or abrasion are validated separately.
Testing on the real part
The 90° bend test was an additional, customer-specific functional test. It complements the requirements of ISO 12870:2024 for unglazed spectacle frames but does not replace proof of conformity with the standard.
Flat test coupons are well suited for checking colour, coating thickness and basic adhesion. However, they do not necessarily reproduce the local strain of a real eyewear frame. The final assessment should therefore be made on the original part or on a geometrically comparable sample.
Checklist: questions to answer before any process development
How much is the part deformed, and what is the smallest bending radius?
Is it deformed once or repeatedly?
Is it assembled before or after coating?
Which surface is under tension during bending?
What additional requirements apply regarding abrasion, sweat, cosmetics or corrosion?
What we take away from this project
Even a proven coating often has untapped potential. For rigid parts, a well-established PVD recipe delivers very good results. When the part is severely deformed, other mechanisms come into play – and that is exactly where targeted process development can make a significant difference.
So the decisive question is not just: which coating produces the desired colour? It is: which coating system produces the desired colour and at the same time withstands the actual load on the part?
We are happy to answer this question for your part, too.
Your coating looks good – but does it hold up to what your part demands?
We refine your PVD process directly on your own coater. You keep production in-house and gain a PVD coating that meets your actual requirements.
Your contact: Christos Pernagidis, +49-151-12460006, cpernagidis@avaluxe.de
About H&U Scheffler
H&U Scheffler GmbH, based in Markranstädt, Germany, has been a partner to the eyewear industry for more than 25 years. The company covers the entire value chain, from metal and polyamide processing and PVD coating to warehousing and shipping to end customers, and is known for its discreet handling of new designs. www.hu-scheffler-gmbh.de

H&U Scheffler GmbH headquarters in Markranstädt, Germany.




Comments